Description
When James Urdang sat down to write his memoir, It Always Seems Impossible, he wasnât only telling the story of a life devoted to education. He was lifting the lid on one of the most shocking battles between a grassroots South African charity and one of the worldâs biggest banks.
In 2017, Lord Hain stunned the House of Lords by naming HSBC and Standard Chartered in connection with ÂŁ400 million in illicit funds linked to the Gupta/Zuma state capture network. Soon after, Urdang came forward with forensic evidence that HSBC itself had engaged in misconduct against Education Africa.
What followed reads like the plot of a political thriller. In 2018, in a formal open letter to the UKâs National Crime Agency, Hain accused HSBC of:
- Changing the locks to the charityâs office and controlling access
- Reckless trading
- Fraudulent access to Education Africaâs bank account
- Unauthorised withdrawals from donor-funded projects
- Deletion of financial records and correspondence
- A defamation campaign, later proven baseless, against the charityâs leadership
âHSBC was a Trustee of Education Africa,â Hain wrote in his 2018 letter, âyet its own executives engaged in dishonesty, corporate bullying, and manipulation against a vulnerable charity. Staff lost jobs, their livelihoods, and one person even lost their home as a result. HSBCâs response was to sweep the matter under the carpet.â What made matters worse, added Lord Hain, was that HSBC Holdings was given every opportunity to put things right, but chose rather not to compensate Education Africa fairly and did not make a public apology to enable the charity to get back on its feetâ. The fallout was devastating for Education Africa. Staff endured intimidation, financial hardship, and broken lives, while HSBC executives kept their posts, bonuses, and pensions.
âWhat HSBC has now done to a vulnerable charity and to those who have given up so much to make our world a better place,â Hain wrote, âis extremely distressing and shocking. This conduct by HSBC, and I am sure I can also speak for millions of British people, people around the world, HSBC shareholders, HSBC depositors, and say âHSBC not in our nameâ.â For Urdang, It Always Seems Impossible is not just an account of betrayal but a testament to resilience. âIt is a reminder,â he says, âthat justice, though often delayed, is never out of reach.â




